Home
»
Best Products
»
Baby Shower Game Prizes: 55 Ideas Guests Actually Want

Baby Shower Game Prizes: 55 Ideas Guests Actually Want

By Betteroo Team ·

Updated

Gift bags with clear wrapping and ribbons, a candle, succulent plant, and stacked boxes on a wooden table set by balloons in the background.

The best baby shower game prizes are small items most guests will actually use or enjoy, such as gourmet treats, candles, hand cream, succulents, coffee samplers and gift cards, with at least one prize for every game you play.

Baby shower game prizes are a small part of the party budget, but they shape how the games feel. A good prize gets a cheer; a forgettable one ends up in a drawer.

Here are 55 prize ideas grouped by type, from treats and self-care to co-ed and eco-friendly picks, plus how many to buy, how to wrap them, alternatives to prizes and a few etiquette questions hosts always ask.

Key Takeaways

  • Plan on at least one prize per game, plus two or three extras for ties.
  • Treats, self-care items and gift cards appeal to the widest range of guests.
  • For co-ed showers, choose neutral prizes like snack samplers, coffee or card games.
  • Skip alcohol for the mom-to-be: the CDC says there is no known safe amount in pregnancy.
  • A diaper raffle, a donation or a prize table can replace individual prizes.

As an Amazon Associate, Betteroo earns from qualifying purchases.

Baby Shower Game Prizes at a Glance

Quick Answer

The best baby shower game prizes are small, useful or treat-yourself items most guests will enjoy: gourmet treats, scented candles, hand cream, succulents, coffee or tea samplers and gift cards. Plan on at least one prize per game, keep them easy to carry home, and choose gender-neutral items for co-ed showers.

The list below is organized by type rather than price, since budgets vary. All ideas are generic categories, so you can pick a version that fits your theme and budget.

Prize typeBest forExamples
Treats and consumablesAny guest, any budgetGourmet chocolate, cookie tins, popcorn, hot sauce sampler
Small home itemsHosts who want keepsakesCandles, succulents, kitchen towels, coasters
Self-careShowers with many moms and friendsHand cream, bath soak, face masks, cozy socks
Kid-free treatsParent guests who need a breakCoffee shop gift card, movie gift card, puzzle book
Practical prizesGuests who prefer useful itemsReusable water bottle, phone charging cable, umbrella
Co-ed prizesShowers with partners and friendsSnack sampler, card game, grilling spice rub
Group and DIY prizesLarge showers and tight budgetsHomemade jam, prize table, seed packets
Eco-friendly prizesLow-waste showersBeeswax wraps, bar soap, a native wildflower seed kit
Baby shower game prize ideas by type.

Planning the games themselves? Our baby shower games guide has 35 ideas, and how to host a baby shower walks through the whole party plan.

Treats and Consumables

Edible prizes are the safest bet: nobody has to find a place for them, and almost everyone likes a treat.

Skip anything that needs refrigeration if the shower runs long, and label ingredients when you can for guests with allergies. If the mom-to-be ends up with edible leftovers, keep in mind that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) advises pregnant women to avoid soft cheeses unless they are labeled as made with pasteurized milk, and to skip hot dogs and luncheon meats unless reheated until steaming hot. Our baby shower food ideas guide covers the menu.

Small Home Items

These prizes feel a bit more special and last longer than a snack.

Candles are a classic prize, but the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) notes that candles are a cause of home fires and home fire deaths. A flameless LED candle is a good alternative for guests with young kids or pets.

Big days go better after a good night of sleep.

Got a baby or toddler at home too? Our free two-minute quiz builds a gentle, personalized sleep plan for little ones.

Take the Free Sleep Quiz

Self-Care Prizes

Small pampering prizes are a hit at most showers, especially with friends who are parents themselves.

Choose light or unscented options where you can, since some guests are sensitive to strong fragrance.

Kid-Free Treats and Experiences

Many shower guests are parents of young kids. A prize that buys them an hour to themselves can be the most appreciated item on the table.

  • Coffee shop gift card for a quiet latte.
  • Movie theater gift card or a streaming rental credit.
  • Bookstore gift card so the winner picks their own read.
  • Puzzle book of crosswords or sudoku.
  • Jigsaw puzzle for a calm evening.
  • Restaurant takeout gift card so someone else cooks one night.
  • Bakery gift card for a sweet treat on the way home.

Gift cards travel well and work for virtual showers, too. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says that under federal law a gift card cannot be sold that will expire in less than five years, and it suggests including the terms and the receipt when you give one. Read the fine print for fees. For online parties, see our virtual baby shower guide.

Practical Prizes Everyone Uses

Practical prizes are especially good when you are not sure who will win, because they suit nearly anyone.

Prizes for Co-Ed Baby Showers

When partners, dads and friends of all genders are playing, pick prizes that are fun, neutral and easy to share.

Need games that work for a mixed crowd? Our gender reveal games list includes several crowd-pleasers.

Group, DIY and Eco-Friendly Prizes

Large showers, tight budgets and low-waste goals all point to the same idea: fewer purchased items, more thought.

  • Homemade cookies or jam in a jar with a handwritten tag.
  • Prize table: winners pick from a table of small items, so nobody gets something they dislike.
  • Seed packets or a small wildflower kit, a nice match for a garden theme.
  • Beeswax food wraps.
  • Bamboo cutlery set for lunches on the go.
  • Bar shampoo or bar soap with no plastic packaging.
  • Potted herb such as basil or mint.
  • Thrifted teacup with a tea bag tucked inside.

A prize table is our favorite trick for big parties: buy a dozen small items in a few categories and let winners choose in the order they win.

How Many Baby Shower Game Prizes to Buy

Plan on at least one prize per game, plus a few extras for ties and runner-up spots. Here is a simple way to estimate:

Shower sizeGamesPrizes to buy
Small, about 10 to 15 guests2 to 3 games4 to 6 prizes
Medium, about 15 to 30 guests3 to 4 games6 to 10 prizes
Large, 30 or more guests3 to 5 games plus a raffle8 to 12 prizes, or a prize table
Rough guide to how many baby shower prizes to buy.
  • Buy two or three extras in case of ties.
  • Decide ahead of time whether you will give first place only or first, second and third.
  • If you run a diaper raffle, plan one larger prize or two or three medium ones.
  • Keep a few small favors for guests who did not win anything, if your budget allows.

How to Wrap and Display Baby Shower Prizes

  • Match the theme: use tissue, paper bags or cello bags in the shower colors.
  • Make them a decoration: line prizes up on a side table with a small sign so they double as decor.
  • Keep wrapping light: winners should be able to tuck prizes into a purse. Small gift bags or kraft boxes work well.
  • Mystery prizes: wrap everything the same so winners pick blind, which adds a little suspense.
  • Label by game: tag each prize with a game name so the host does not have to decide in the moment.

Prize Alternatives and Etiquette

Prizes are optional. If they do not fit your budget or style, try one of these instead:

  • Diaper raffle: guests bring a pack of diapers in exchange for a raffle ticket, and one name is drawn for a prize at the end. The parents-to-be get a stack of diapers.
  • Donate in the winner’s name: make a small donation to a cause the parents care about. The National Diaper Bank Network says 1 in 2 U.S. families struggles with diaper need, so a local diaper bank is a natural fit.
  • Bragging rights: a paper crown or a silly certificate can be enough for a casual crowd.
  • Book exchange: guests bring a children’s book for the baby’s library, and winners choose first from a basket of adult paperbacks.

Etiquette tips

  • The guest of honor: the parents-to-be usually play for fun and pass any prize they win to the runner-up. Some hosts give the mom-to-be her own small gift instead.
  • Skip alcohol for the mom-to-be: wine or spirits can make good prizes for other adult guests, but the CDC says there is no known safe amount of alcohol use during pregnancy. If the pregnant guest could win, choose a non-alcoholic prize.
  • Who pays: the host usually covers prizes. If several friends co-host, split the cost ahead of time.
  • Thank-you notes: guests do not need to send thank-you notes for game prizes, but a thank-you from the host to anyone who donated prizes is kind.

For the main gift, see our baby shower gift ideas, and for the card, what to write in a baby shower card. Planning a post-baby gathering instead? Read our sip and see party guide.

Related Betteroo Guides

The Bottom Line

Good baby shower game prizes are small, useful and easy to take home. Pick a mix of treats, self-care, practical and kid-free items, buy at least one prize per game plus a few extras, and keep alcohol out of the mix for the mom-to-be. If prizes are not in the budget, a diaper raffle, a donation or simple bragging rights work just as well.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are good baby shower game prizes?

Good baby shower game prizes are small and useful or fun: gourmet chocolate, cookies, scented or flameless candles, succulents, hand cream, lip balm sets, coffee or tea samplers, cozy socks and gift cards. Gender-neutral items like snack samplers and card games work well at co-ed showers. Pick things guests can carry home easily.

How many prizes do you need for a baby shower?

Plan on at least one prize for each game you play, plus two or three extras for ties. If you give second and third place prizes, multiply accordingly. A shower with three or four games usually needs six to ten prizes. A prize table lets large groups pick from a set of small items.

Do you have to give prizes for baby shower games?

No. Prizes are a nice tradition but not required. Many hosts skip them or replace them with a diaper raffle, a donation in the winner’s name, a paper crown or simple bragging rights. Guests come to celebrate the parents-to-be, so games can be fun on their own.

Can the mom-to-be win baby shower games?

She can play, but by tradition the guest of honor usually passes any prize she wins to the runner-up, since she is already receiving gifts. Some hosts give her a separate small prize. If she might win, avoid alcohol, since the CDC says there is no known safe amount during pregnancy.

What is a diaper raffle at a baby shower?

In a diaper raffle, each guest who brings a pack of diapers gets a raffle ticket. At the end of the shower, the host draws a ticket and the winner receives a prize. The parents-to-be get a supply of diapers, and guests get a chance to win something nice.

What should you not give as a baby shower prize?

Avoid alcohol if the mom-to-be could win, strongly scented items for guests who may be sensitive, foods that need refrigeration during a long party, and anything bulky or fragile that is hard to carry home. Also skip joke prizes that could embarrass a guest.

Gentle changes, peaceful nights.

Betteroo builds a personalized sleep plan for your baby or toddler. Take the free two-minute quiz to get started.

Take the Free Sleep Quiz

5 Sources
  1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About Alcohol Use During Pregnancy.
    https://www.cdc.gov/alcohol-pregnancy/about/index.html
  2. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Food Safety for Moms-to-Be: At-a-Glance.
    https://www.fda.gov/food/people-risk-foodborne-illness/food-safety-mom-be-glance
  3. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Giving or Receiving Gift Cards? Know the Terms and Avoid Surprises.
    https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/blog/giving-or-receiving-gift-cards-know-the-terms-and-avoid-surprises/
  4. National Fire Protection Association. Candles.
    https://www.nfpa.org/education-and-research/home-fire-safety/candles
  5. National Diaper Bank Network.
    https://nationaldiaperbanknetwork.org/