Home
»
Pregnancy
»
Does Sperm Determine Gender? X and Y Sperm, Myths and What Science Says

Does Sperm Determine Gender? X and Y Sperm, Myths and What Science Says

Updated

An expecting couple sitting together on a sofa, one with a hand resting on the other's early pregnancy belly
Rachel Rothman, Co-Founder and Chief Parenting Officer at Betteroo

Written By

Rachel Rothman

Chief Parenting Officer

Dr. Meidad Greenberg, Board-Certified Pediatrician and Pediatric Medical Advisor at Betteroo

Medically Reviewed By

Meidad Greenberg, M.D.

Board-Certified Pediatrician

Does sperm determine gender? Yes: the egg always carries an X chromosome, so whether the sperm that fertilizes it carries an X or a Y sets your baby’s chromosomal sex at conception.

If you are wondering whether you can influence having a boy or a girl, or whose genes decide it, the short answer is that the sperm decides, and it does so by chance the moment it reaches the egg.

Below: X and Y sperm, why more boys are born, what research says about popular myths, family history, medical sex selection, and when you can find out.

Key Takeaways

  • The egg always carries an X; the sperm carries an X or a Y, so the sperm sets chromosomal sex.
  • About 105 boys are born for every 100 girls in the U.S., per CDC birth data.
  • Timing sex around ovulation does not change the baby’s sex, per a 1995 NEJM study.
  • A study of 4.7 million Swedish births found no genetic tendency to have boys or girls.
  • NIPT can show sex from 10 weeks; the anatomy scan usually can at 18 to 22 weeks.

Does Sperm Determine Gender? The Short Answer

Quick Answer

Yes. The sperm decides your baby’s chromosomal sex at the moment of fertilization. The egg always carries an X chromosome. Each sperm carries either an X or a Y. An X sperm makes an XX embryo, which typically develops as a girl, and a Y sperm makes an XY embryo, which typically develops as a boy. Cleveland Clinic puts the odds for any one pregnancy at roughly 50/50.

MedlinePlus Genetics, the National Library of Medicine’s genetics reference, explains that females usually have two X chromosomes and males usually have one X and one Y. Because the egg can only pass on an X, the chromosome that varies comes from the sperm.

X Sperm vs Y Sperm: What Is the Difference?

A father has one X and one Y chromosome, and each sperm he makes passes on just one of them. Cleveland Clinic explains that the biological father contributes either an X or a Y, which is why the sperm, not the egg, decides chromosomal sex. Which sperm reaches and fertilizes the egg is a matter of chance.

The Y chromosome matters because of one gene in particular. MedlinePlus Genetics says sex is determined by the SRY gene on the Y chromosome, which is responsible for a fetus developing as male. Other genes on the Y are involved in male development and fertility.

X-bearing spermY-bearing sperm
Sex chromosome it carriesXY
Embryo it makes with the egg’s XXXXY
Typical developmentFemaleMale (driven by the SRY gene)
Faster or tougher?Not provenNot proven
X vs Y sperm. Sources: MedlinePlus Genetics (NIH); Cleveland Clinic.

You will often read that Y sperm are smaller and faster while X sperm are slower but hardier. That idea comes from the Shettles method (more on it below). Cleveland Clinic notes that research has disproven the idea that X and Y sperm are structurally different, so the “fast boy sperm, tough girl sperm” story does not hold up.

Sex vs Gender: Why the Words Matter Here

Most people search “does sperm determine gender,” so we use that phrase too. In medicine, the word for what chromosomes decide is sex: the biological traits such as chromosomes, hormones and anatomy that your provider sees on tests and scans. Gender usually refers to identity and how a person understands and expresses who they are, which grows over a lifetime and is not read from a chromosome.

So the precise answer is: the sperm determines chromosomal sex, which is what doctors mean when they talk about learning the sex at a scan. Many parents also like gender-neutral names that work no matter what the scan shows.

Why Slightly More Boys Are Born

Slightly more boys than girls are born. The National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS), part of the CDC, studied U.S. births from 1940 to 2002 and found the sex ratio ranged from 1,046 to 1,059 boys per 1,000 girls. That works out to roughly 105 boys for every 100 girls.

NCHS found small differences by the mother’s age (1,054 for mothers aged 15 to 19 vs 1,038 for ages 40 to 44) and by race and ethnicity, and noted that the more children a woman has, the more likely her children are to even out between boys and girls. These are population patterns across millions of births. They do not let you predict or change the sex of your own baby.

Baby on the way? Get ahead on sleep.

Our free two-minute quiz builds a gentle, personalized sleep plan you can use from the first weeks at home.

Take the Free Sleep Quiz

Does the Shettles Method Work?

The Shettles method is the most famous plan for choosing a baby’s sex. Cleveland Clinic explains that it was developed in the 1960s by Dr. Landrum Shettles, an American OB/GYN, and that his theories have since been debunked.

  • The theory: Y sperm are lighter and faster but die sooner; X sperm are slower but last longer.
  • For a boy: have sex on the day of ovulation and up to two or three days after, with deep penetration.
  • For a girl: have sex in the days after your period, then stop two or three days before ovulation, with shallow penetration.
  • Extras: douching with vinegar for a girl or baking soda for a boy, and rules about orgasm timing.

The best test of the timing idea is a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1995. Allen Wilcox and colleagues followed 221 healthy women trying to conceive, tracking ovulation with daily urine hormone tests and logging intercourse. Boys and girls were conceived with similar patterns of intercourse around ovulation. The authors concluded that, for practical purposes, the timing of sex in relation to ovulation has no influence on the sex of the baby.

Cleveland Clinic adds that douching does not change the odds for either sex and can be harmful, so skip it. The same study did find something useful for anyone trying to get pregnant: conception happened only when sex fell in a six-day window ending on the day of ovulation. Our guide to preparing for pregnancy covers tracking that fertile window.

Other Boy or Girl Myths: Positions, Diet and the Chinese Calendar

MythWhat it claimsWhat the evidence says
Sex positionsDeep penetration favors boys, shallow favors girlsCleveland Clinic: deeper intercourse does not change how sperm reach the egg
Timing sexNear ovulation for a boy, earlier for a girlWilcox 1995 (NEJM): timing has no practical influence on sex
DietMore potassium or salty foods for a boyCleveland Clinic: one study offered only minimal proof and a small shift
DouchingVinegar for a girl, baking soda for a boyCleveland Clinic: false and potentially harmful
Chinese calendarMother’s age plus month of conception predicts sexNo biological basis: sex is set by the sperm, which the chart ignores
Common sex-selection myths and what sources say.

The Chinese gender calendar is fun, but notice what it leaves out: the father. Since the chromosome that decides sex comes from the sperm, a chart based only on the mother’s age and the month cannot know which sperm fertilized the egg. Our old wives’ tales gender guide walks through the calendar and 19 other tales, from carrying high to heart rate. If guessing is part of the fun, try our gender reveal games and treat any prediction as entertainment.

Do Boys or Girls Run in the Father’s Family?

You may have heard that a man with many brothers is more likely to have sons. This idea has been studied, and the evidence that it is inherited is weak.

The largest study so far, published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B in 2020 by Brendan Zietsch and colleagues, used Swedish population registers covering about 3.5 million people and their 4.7 million children. The researchers found no genetic contribution to whether parents had sons or daughters. The sex of each child looked close to chance.

Scientists still debate the details, so the question is not fully closed. But a family full of boys does not mean your next baby will be a boy, and family history on either side cannot tell you what you are having. Three boys or three girls in a row happens by chance, just as three coin flips can land the same way.

Can You Choose Your Baby’s Sex? PGT and Sperm Sorting

Without medical help, there is no proven way to change the odds. With medical help, the picture is different.

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT). Cleveland Clinic describes this as the only way to guarantee a baby’s sex. It is done with in vitro fertilization (IVF): eggs are fertilized in a lab, often using a technique called intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), and before an embryo is transferred to the uterus, a cell from it is tested. That test shows the embryo’s sex before any embryo is transferred.

Sperm sorting. You may also see lab methods advertised that try to separate X-bearing from Y-bearing sperm before insemination or IVF. Because Cleveland Clinic names PGT as the only way to guarantee sex, treat any sorting method as, at most, a change in odds rather than a promise, and ask a fertility clinic for its own published success data.

IVF involves medications, procedures and real costs, and clinic policies on nonmedical sex selection vary. A reproductive endocrinologist can explain your options.

When Can You Find Out Your Baby’s Sex?

TestTypical timingWhat to know
NIPT (cell-free DNA blood test)From 10 weeksShows whether XX or XY is present; highly accurate, but not 100% (Cleveland Clinic)
Anatomy ultrasoundAround 18 to 22 weeksIn most cases the sex can be seen, depending on the baby’s position (Cleveland Clinic)
At birthDeliverySome families choose to wait for the surprise
When you can learn your baby’s sex. Sources: Cleveland Clinic NIPT and 20-week ultrasound pages.

NIPT (noninvasive prenatal testing) is a screening test done on a sample of your blood. Cleveland Clinic says it can be done from 10 weeks of pregnancy. Because it screens for sex chromosome conditions, it can also tell whether XX or XY chromosomes are present. Remember that NIPT is a screening test: it estimates risk and does not diagnose conditions. See 10 weeks pregnant for what else is happening around then.

The anatomy scan, often called the 20-week ultrasound, happens around 18 to 22 weeks. Cleveland Clinic says that in most cases you can learn the sex at this scan, depending on the baby’s position, and notes that, as with any scan, false results are possible. Read more in 20 weeks pregnant.

Tell your provider ahead of time whether you want to know. For ways to share the news, see our gender reveal ideas.

Intersex Traits and Differences of Sex Development

For most babies, XX or XY tells the whole story. For some, sex development takes a different path, and families deserve accurate, kind information about that too. The medical term is differences (or disorders) of sex development (DSD), and many people and advocacy groups use the word intersex.

  • Different chromosome combinations: Cleveland Clinic lists Turner syndrome, Klinefelter syndrome, Triple X syndrome and XYY syndrome as the most common sex chromosome conditions NIPT screens for. MedlinePlus Genetics also describes conditions such as 47,XYY and 48,XXYY.
  • SRY in an unexpected place: MedlinePlus Genetics explains that in 46,XX testicular DSD, the SRY gene has usually moved onto an X chromosome, so a person with two X chromosomes develops as male.

A screening result or scan that raises a question about sex development is not a diagnosis. Ask for a referral to a genetic counselor, who can explain what it means and what follow-up makes sense.

Related Betteroo Guides

When to Talk to Your Doctor or Midwife

Questions about your baby’s sex are almost never urgent, but some situations are worth a conversation:

  • You are planning a pregnancy and want to talk through fertility timing, family history or genetic carrier screening.
  • You are considering IVF with PGT, for medical reasons or otherwise, and want to understand the process, risks and costs.
  • An NIPT result or ultrasound shows something unexpected about the sex chromosomes or sex development. Ask about genetic counseling.
  • You want to know whether, when and how your baby’s sex will be shared with you.

Any time in pregnancy, call 911 or go to the emergency room for heavy vaginal bleeding, severe belly pain, fainting, chest pain or trouble breathing. Call your provider’s office the same day for lighter bleeding, cramping that worries you, or fewer baby movements later in pregnancy. Trust your instincts and call if something feels wrong.

Whatever you are hoping for, our baby girl names and baby boy names lists are ready when you are.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does sperm determine gender or does the egg?

The sperm determines it. Every egg carries an X chromosome, while each sperm carries either an X or a Y. An X sperm makes an XX embryo, which typically develops as a girl, and a Y sperm makes an XY embryo, which typically develops as a boy. Cleveland Clinic notes this is set at conception.

Which sperm is faster, boy or girl?

The claim that Y sperm are faster and X sperm are hardier comes from the Shettles method of the 1960s. Cleveland Clinic says research has disproven the idea that X and Y sperm are structurally different, and a 1995 New England Journal of Medicine study found intercourse timing has no practical effect on the baby’s sex.

Can you increase your chances of having a girl or a boy naturally?

No method without medical help has been shown to work. Timing sex, positions, douching and diet changes have not held up in research, and Cleveland Clinic calls douching potentially harmful. Each pregnancy stays close to a 50/50 chance, with slightly more boys born overall, about 105 for every 100 girls.

Does having boys or girls run in families?

The evidence for that is weak. A 2020 study of about 4.7 million births in Sweden found no genetic contribution to whether parents had sons or daughters, and each child’s sex looked close to chance. Several children of the same sex in one family usually happens by chance, like a run of coin flips.

Is there any way to guarantee a baby’s sex?

Cleveland Clinic says the only way to guarantee it is preimplantation genetic testing during IVF, where a cell from each embryo is tested before transfer. IVF involves medications, procedures and real costs, and clinic policies for nonmedical use vary. A fertility specialist can explain your options.

How early can you find out the sex of a baby?

Cleveland Clinic says NIPT, a blood screening test, can be done from 10 weeks of pregnancy and can show whether XX or XY chromosomes are present, though it is not 100 percent accurate. The anatomy ultrasound at about 18 to 22 weeks usually shows the sex too, depending on the baby’s position.

Calmer days, better nights.

Betteroo builds a personalized sleep plan for your baby. Take the free two-minute quiz and have it ready before the newborn weeks.

Take the Free Sleep Quiz

7 Sources
  1. MedlinePlus Genetics (National Library of Medicine, NIH). Y chromosome.
    https://medlineplus.gov/genetics/chromosome/y/
  2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics. More Boys Born Than Girls (Trend Analysis of the Sex Ratio at Birth in the United States, 1940 to 2002). June 14, 2005.
    https://www.cdc.gov/media/pressrel/fs050614.htm
  3. Wilcox AJ, Weinberg CR, Baird DD. Timing of sexual intercourse in relation to ovulation: effects on the probability of conception, survival of the pregnancy, and sex of the baby. N Engl J Med. 1995;333(23):1517-1521. PubMed.
    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7477165/
  4. Zietsch BP, Walum H, Lichtenstein P, Verweij KJH, Kuja-Halkola R. No genetic contribution to variation in human offspring sex ratio: a total population study of 4.7 million births. Proc R Soc B. 2020;287(1921):20192849.
    https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2019.2849
  5. Cleveland Clinic. Boy or Girl? Can You Choose Your Baby’s Sex?
    https://health.clevelandclinic.org/boy-or-girl-can-you-choose-your-babys-sex/
  6. Cleveland Clinic. NIPT Test (Noninvasive Prenatal Testing).
    https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diagnostics/21050-nipt-test
  7. Cleveland Clinic. 20 Week Ultrasound (Anatomy Scan).
    https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diagnostics/22644-20-week-ultrasound